?

Log in

No account? Create an account
December 2017   01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
QuillWe

The Political And The Personal

Posted on 2009.01.04 at 21:05
Current Mood: contemplativecontemplative
Current Music: It Takes All Kinds to Make a World - Roger Miller
I’ve been moved to write this post as a reaction to the current violence occurring between Israel and Hamas. The connection will become more explicit further down the page.

* * *

On more than one occasion, I’ve been asked by readers of this journal why I never take on the hot-button political issues of the day in my writings. After all, such topics are the raw fuel powering many widely read blogs. Well, I think it’s time I took another stab at addressing such questions.

First of all, I have nothing against politically-oriented blogs. As a matter of fact, I read several of them regularly. But it comes down to a question of what I feel moved to write about; that is, what matters to me, and what I want to explore through my own written words. Well, what matters to me are people, their emotions, and their perceptions; not broader political matters. Oh, I realize that politics matter – they affect all of us, whether we want them to or not. But my opinions about political matters are not what gets my creative juices flowing. Rather, I get revved up by direct, personal interaction with people, places, and things. After all, that is what we spend our lives doing, so I believe such things are far more central to our existence than the contemplation of national and international politics. On top of that is the fact that if I were to present myself as a political commentator, I would be putting myself out on the same playing field as a great many individuals for whom I have no respect; people who are naïve at best and slimy at worst. While I have friends who revel in such commentary, who like nothing better than to take on the rhetoric of political fools and villains, this is not the battlefield for me.

Here’s an imaginary example that might make my position clearer – if I ran into Mayor Daley by the deli counter at the supermarket, you can be sure that I’d write about it in this journal. I’d probably never talk about his politics or mine; I’d write about the man; that is, the man I ran into at the supermarket. I might compare that interaction to the public persona given to us over the airwaves, and I’d invite my readers to do the same. I’d talk about what he was buying and maybe even what he was wearing.

One simple reason for this approach is that it would permit me to tell you what I knew from first-hand experience. Not what I’d heard some clever pundit say; not what I’d read in someone’s editorial commentary; you don’t need to go to my blog to read such things. Better that I should simply relate what I myself had observed and discerned. By comparing those first-hand impressions with more general, public information, I would hope that a more three-dimensional portrait of the individual would begin to emerge. And maybe, just maybe, you’d find a slant here that you wouldn’t find anywhere else.

So, as I mentioned at the outset, we come to the never-ending violence and institutionalized hatred that permeates so much of the Middle East. A more political blog might go into great detail on the subject, and might even take sides in terms of being for or against Israel’s actions. But you’re not at one of those blogs; you’re at my blog, so I will address the matter with something I directly experienced.

It was a couple of years ago during a performance of Tony n’ Tina’s Wedding. One gets very accustomed to performing for a wide variety of audience types – different, faiths, cultures, languages, etc. We’ve had audience members whose English was quite limited, and it always pleased me to see such people laughing and enjoying the show, because it told me we were tapping into something basic and powerful. On one particular night, we had a family – father, mother, and son – who identified themselves as Palestinian. There was no reason to doubt them. Frankly, they looked the part and sounded the part. They knew a fair amount of English, though it was obviously a (distant) second language for them.

They seemed to be having a good time until we reached the point in the show known as the International Medley. As part of that medley, we sing a couple verses of “Hava Nagila” and dance the Hora, which, as you are probably aware, is solidly Jewish in its ethnic identity. No sooner had the Hora begun when the Palestinian family jumped to their feet, gathered their things, and stalked out, never to return. They looked completely offended, as if someone had just dumped goat feces in their lasagna. They also looked as if every moment they had to listen to “Hava Nagila” was a painful eternity to their assaulted ears, and they could not get out of there fast enough. On their way out, they tersely informed one cast member that they were indeed quite offended that such a reference would be a part of our show.

I could not help feeling badly for them. Let me be clear about that – I did not feel badly that we had played “Hava Nagila.” I did not feel badly that they had heard “Hava Nagila.” I felt badly for them because they were offended at being subjected to anything of a Jewish nature, and I felt sorry for them that they could not let go of this for even a moment. Now I’m perfectly aware that many people would consider their actions to be understandable and even justifiable. Such people might be willing to spend hours telling me of the atrocities dealt to the Palestinians by the Jews. I am no stranger to this mind set, and I will not even attempt to argue with thousands of years of history. My point is this – these people were in Chicago. In America. In multi-cultural America. If they are going to spend time in this country, they must come to terms with the realities of American society. If they cannot do this, they are going to find it impossible to walk down most any busy street, for they will be assaulted constantly by people, symbols, and signs that will infuriate them. My primary hope is that they will stay here long enough to learn a little tolerance. Mind you, I don’t like the odds, but it is my hope for them. And all I can do is hope, for there seems no reason to think that I have any ability to affect their feelings in this matter.

This, then, is my way of addressing political matters here – by relating a moment from my own life and inviting readers to draw their own conclusions if they wish, though even the notion of drawing conclusions is completely optional. Sometimes, we are left not knowing what to think and can only shake our heads, remember the moment, and move on.

Previous Entry  Next Entry